News Center

Comparison of Chloride Ion Corrosion Resistance Among Different Materials

1.Conventional Stainless Steel: A Choice Under Limited Conditions

Conventional stainless steel is not entirely unsuitable for chloride-containing environments, but its use is subject to strict limitations:

304 Stainless Steel: Suitable for environments with chloride ion content ≤200 ppm

316/316L Stainless Steel: Offers superior chloride ion resistance compared to 304, suitable for conditions with chloride ion content <1000ppm

Note: Water quality standards for chloride ions are typically stricter. For instance, relevant specifications require chloride ion content in water not to exceed 25mg/L (25ppm) during hydraulic testing.

When chloride concentrations exceed limits or temperatures are high, ordinary stainless steel may develop pitting corrosion. One engineer shared this experience: “Stainless steel valves in calcium chloride-fed frozen brine systems are less durable than ordinary carbon steel valves, yet cost at least twice as much—they're generally not used.”

2.Premium Stainless Steel: Enhanced Corrosion Resistance

When chloride ion concentrations are higher, consider higher-grade stainless steel materials:

317 Stainless Steel: Resistant to chloride ion concentrations <5000 ppm

904L Stainless Steel: Suitable for environments with moderate chloride ion concentrations

254SMO: A super austenitic stainless steel offering exceptional resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion

3.Duplex Stainless Steel: A Balance of Strength and Corrosion Resistance

Duplex stainless steel exhibits exceptional resistance to chloride-induced stress corrosion cracking due to its unique ferritic-austenitic dual-phase structure:

2205 Duplex Steel: Comparable chloride pitting resistance to 904L

2507 Duplex Steel: Chloride pitting resistance rivaling 254SMO

The yield strength of duplex stainless steel reaches ≥450 MPa, significantly exceeding that of conventional stainless steel, making it particularly suitable for high-pressure environments.

4.Titanium and Titanium Alloys: The Top Choice for High Chloride Ion Environments

Titanium materials exhibit near-total immunity to high chloride ion environments, making them ideal for seawater and other highly chloride-rich media:

Pure Titanium TA1/TA2: Safe for use in seawater below 120°C

Titanium-Palladium Alloys and Titanium-Nickel-Molybdenum Alloys: Suitable for high-temperature pressurized seawater environments up to 260°C

Experiments demonstrate that while C276 nickel-based alloys exhibit pitting corrosion at 204°C in a 3000ppm chloride environment, titanium materials show no signs of corrosion.

5.Special Alloys: The Ultimate Solution for Extreme Conditions

For extreme conditions involving high temperatures, high pressures, and severe corrosion, special alloys serve as the last line of defense:

Hastelloy (e.g., C-276): Resists concentrated hydrochloric acid, sulfuric acid, and other highly corrosive media

Monel: Exhibits outstanding corrosion resistance against hydrofluoric acid

These specialty alloys are costly, typically 5-8 times the price of standard stainless steel, and are selected only when absolutely necessary.

6.Non-metallic Materials: Low-Cost Solutions

Non-metallic valves offer an economical choice for low-pressure, ambient-temperature applications:

PTFE (Polytetrafluoroethylene): The corrosion-resistant champion, withstanding nearly all acids and alkalis

PVDF (Polyvinylidene Fluoride): Higher strength than PTFE, suitable for medium-concentration acids

Lined Valves: PTFE-lined metal bodies combine strength with corrosion resistance

Non-metallic valves typically suit applications with pressure ≤1.6MPa and temperature ≤260°C.

Practical Material Selection Guide: Match materials to operating conditions

For practical application, the following material selection recommendations are provided based on different operating conditions:

Low chloride concentration (<200 ppm), ambient temperature: 304 stainless steel is suitable. Ensure designs avoid dead corners and gaps to minimize chloride accumulation.

Moderate chloride concentration (200–5000 ppm), moderate temperature: 316/317 stainless steel or duplex stainless steel. Consider coating technologies to enhance corrosion resistance.

High chloride ion concentration (e.g., seawater), high temperature: Prefer titanium alloys or high-grade duplex stainless steel. Avoid titanium materials if the medium contains fluoride ions.

Strongly corrosive media (e.g., hydrochloric acid, hydrofluoric acid) + chloride ions: Fluorinated-lined valves or Hastelloy/Monel alloys. Carefully consider seal face materials to ensure compatibility with the valve body's corrosion resistance.

High-concentration chloride ions (e.g., seawater), high temperatures: Titanium alloys or high-grade duplex steel are preferred. Avoid titanium materials if the medium contains fluoride ions.

Three Key Principles for Valve Material Selection

No “Universal Material”

Each material has its specific application range. For instance, Hastelloy is susceptible to concentrated nitric acid, while titanium alloys are vulnerable to hydrofluoric acid. Material selection must be based on the specific characteristics of the medium.

Consider Comprehensive Operating Conditions

Beyond chloride ion concentration, factors like temperature, pressure, pH level, and the presence of solid particles must be evaluated. For instance, corrosion rates may double for every 10°C increase in temperature.

Prioritize Sealing Surface Materials

Valve leakage often stems from sealing surface corrosion. Ensure the corrosion resistance of sealing surface materials matches that of the valve body.

If there is any infringement, please contact us for deletion.